Who Set This Stage?

A phantom limb is an odd fact of human experience. Someone loses an arm, sometimes years later they can still feel it. The hand may seem clenched, and fingers can still ache. The absent limb might occupy a precise position in space, like the body has retained an experience it can no longer support.

Humans tend to regard the body as the most immediate and indisputable part of reality. Yet even here, inside us, the relationship between physical existence and conscious experience isn’t straightforward. Our sense of body ownership depends on the integration of senses, including touch and vision, and signals from within us. Experiments like the rubber hand illusion demonstrate that this sense of oneness can be manipulated. The boundaries of the self, at least as experienced, are not quite as fixed as they seem.

We feel phantom pain, we wince at something that never happened to us.

This demonstrates something small but notable: the experience of reality isn’t just reality arriving intact.

So what does that have to do being an American in our politics today? Maybe nothing… maybe everything.

We encounter the world through systems that organize, interpret, and combine information. We smell, we feel. Touch gives us this precise resistance, a temperature, texture, and pressure. Vision gives us the distance, shape, color, and movement. Any object we recognize emerges through these different encounters.

There’s a distinction between the thing and our experience of the thing, but it seems so negligible that most of the time, we have little reason to think about it…

The cognitive scientist Donald Hoffman has built a much more ambitious theory around this distinction. His “Interface Theory of Perception” proposes that time has shaped perception to provide information useful for survival, but not necessarily to recreate an accurate picture of “objective” reality.

In this account, the physical objects we experience are more like icons on a computer interface than faithful representations of what exists independently of us.

The intuition extends well beyond perception. It touches something like politics I think.

Our culture is rife with things beyond the veil. Mathematics gives us ways to describe dimensions outside ordinary experience. Religion gives consciousness continuing beyond this life.

Across philosophy and culture, we return to the possibility that the world available to us is not the whole of what exists. We are sure we could conceive of realities that our ordinary experience can’t accommodate, while remaining unable to establish what lies beyond it.

So it’s worth naming that society is built from arrangements that acquire the force of reality through collective recognition and institutional power. Money, property, citizenship, corporations, borders are some of the arrangements we experience without any care for our own innate feel of reality; we learn to navigate them as though they were simply part of the world as it already is…. Because it is, right?

Political power operates within some similar constructed reality, but its public presentation is only one part of it. This is harder to name. But imagine we’re given a visible account of power through elections, leaders, parties, and ideological conflicts. You might be encouraged to understand the country through these figures and their competing narratives.

Meanwhile, the durable relationships among wealth, institutions, industry, government, and influence are harder to see and harder to bring into public debate. These are now the things up for debate. Political spectacle gives us a cast of characters and a succession of conflicts; and the underlying distribution of power is a much larger story, somehow harder to write down, and it requires of us tedium and objection; argument and acquiescence.

What am I trying to say here?

The public narrative helps determine what people regard as politically possible. The Overton window defines the problems that demand attention, the interests that appear legitimate, whatever boundaries of acceptable debate here set. A society can argue fiercely over its leaders while leaving the arrangements that constrain those leaders largely untouched. The spectacle becomes the public’s principal way of encountering power, even as power continues to operate through relationships that rarely become part of the spectacle….

The person (you and I) occupies an equally strange position within this order. We experience ourselves as independent people, with private histories, judgment, and desires. Of that we are sure. Yet institutions encounter us through categories they have already established: citizen, employee, tenant, taxpayer, consumer.

Those categories determine how we’re governed, what we are permitted to do, and whether harm reaches us. These become durable descriptions of people, but they also become conditions and containers of our actual lives.

It’s not really relevant to question whether senses reveal reality accurately. We know what we see on TV, online, and in the discourse form only a part of the iceberg. But how this reaches into the social world, where we construct systems, become subject to them, and eventually mistake their historical arrangements for the natural order of things… this still feels unexamined to me. I want to understand this more, because I can see it on the ground.

The world we encounter is shaped both by what exists independently of us and by the structures through which we have learned to recognize, organize, and govern it.

If we’re individuals living inside a reality we didn’t choose, with only partial knowledge of the forces that shape it, the limits of that knowledge may be the most consequential part of our inheritance. Because we come to experience this world as though it could never have been otherwise.

Next
Next

The Realignment: Cyberwar, the Republican civil war, and the Trump-Xi-Putin summit